The Rest of the Story

GenRolly Speaking:Political insights by columnist Paul Rolly.

Friday, October 20, 2006

The Rest of the Story
I wrote on this blog Wednesday about the lawsuit filed by Republican activists Jim Decker, Ella Duke-Baxter and Maxine Barney, claiming their constitutional rights were violated because another person, not the plaintiffs, was allegedly barred from participating in Republican events.The lawsuit stemmed from the fact that 3rd District Judge Sandra Peuler issued an injunction against Republican activist Mike Ridgway, barring him from having any contact with Republican rival Mark Towner and his family.

It also alleged Republican leaders had stopped Ridgway from participating in certain Republican events.But Ridgway was not a plaintiff in the suit and the plaintiffs showed no damage to themselves as a result of the actions regarding Ridgway.

Federal Judge Ted Stewart dismissed the lawsuit as frivolous. No kidding? Stewart must have drawn the short stick. Before he reviewed the case and issued his order, federal judges Dee Benson, J. Thomas Greene, Bruce Jenkins and David Sam all recused themselves from the case, asking the court clerk to find someone else to hear it.Meanwhile, it appears the defendants Towner, Peuler and a group the lawsuit describes as "Utah State Republican Boss Hogs" were not even notified of the suit that was filed several months ago, nor were they served with any documents, as defendants in a case usually are.It seems Towner and Peuler would have been pretty easy to find for notification, although it is conceded that Republican Party "Boss Hogs" might have been a little difficult to track down.

On another matter: I erred in my blog earlier this week when I said State Reps. Jim Dunnigan of Taylorsville and Wayne Harper of West Jordan were running against each other for House Majority Whip. Dunnigan is running for assistant whip. So he will be vying against current Assistant Whip Ben Ferry of Corinne and Brad Dee of Washington Terrace.Harper is running for majority whip against Becky Lockhart of Provo and Gordon Snow of Roosevelt.I had made the point that if Harper and Dunnigan were running against each other, they would cancel each other out among the Salt Lake County vote and ensure the election of a non-Salt Lake County representative. But they are not running against each other so that argument is moot.I had compared them to Democrats in Salt Lake City who keep running against each other for mayor and cancelling each other out. So, apparently, Salt Lake County Republicans are not as foolish as Salt Lake City Democrats after all.Cheers,Paul Rolly
2:33 PM 0 comments